Quote:
Originally Posted by Greenslade
A guna being an attribute of our nature, perhaps what Jung might have termed as an archetype.
|
Sorry Greenslade. Gunas is not like archetype. I googled and seen what Jungian archetype means, and it says, " Archetypes are Universal and derive from the collective Unconscious, where collective Unconscious are inherited by ancestors".
No..Gunas are not inherited like beliefs, myths, etc... It is there as a law. See, how come ancestors have felt the behaviour from nowhere, if it was not there before their presence??
Jungian theory is also have limitations. Something from nowhere, something not exist before, cannot come into existence, when it was first experienced by the first-most ancestor.
Those gunas, or archetypes is not created from/by ancestors. It is, as a law/order, present always, before the creation of universe, and it will present even after cessation of universe. It is not influenced/created by any person.
It is there, as a subtle, eternally. In gita words, both Purusha and Prakriti (three gunas) are eternal. Both are eternal. The flow flows. It comes from subtle to gross and goes back to subtle and to gross and on and on and on. It has no relationship with Purusha.
In jungian terms, conscious(Purusha) does not have any relationship to Unconscious (Prakriti). Both exists always.
It's only the bondage. If Purusha bonds with prakriti, one gets caught in 'ego'. But, one can be, without influenced by the flow and not influencing the flow.
Gunas, like electrons protons neutrons, comes and goes to subtle and present always as a law. If it was not there in subtle form, it cannot be experienced in first-hand gross form for the first time. It cannot come/create from nowhere by people.
AlL sexual, physical things are bound to three gunas. One dominates other every time, and it has nothing in relation to Purusha.
Spiritual, is only related to Purusha. It is called atman-brahman-soul-buddha-and in many names. But, it has nothing to do with physical/psych/any realms. Only modern asadhgurus, speak some "prakriti" as "purusha" itself in misunderstanding. Any experience in this world, any experience in psych, any experience in prana or other realms, angels and demons, all are bound to three gunas, one dominates other two.
But, they are nothing to do with Soul. Like in my profile pic, the sleeping vishnu, nothing to do with reclining Vishnu with Lakshmi inside the bubble.
Jung failed to understand nature. Nature is also eternal. Unconscious things he grouped, has not come from people, but exists always with no relation to conscious.
And sir, in language I have to use "I am" or anything. But those words don't affect me. If it affects you and have a wrong perception about me, let it be that way. I have nothing to do about it, as it is not you wrongly perceiving, but the tamasic guna, dominates in the situation/flow, so it happens to be. I see no person to prove anything.
And you still didn't answered to the post #245. It's fine. It's rajasic guna domination, to preserve the 'ego' or things to hide, so to forcast a better image about 'ego'.
Take care.