Is a spiritual guide always right?

[pasc345]

I heard the voice of my spiritual guide a few time ago telling me that I will see a certain person on Christmas time. It was very clear.. it almost felt like I was talking to another person.
I would like to know... is it for sure that what the guide said will happen... or can the guide be wrong sometimes? should I expect it?

[Shinsoo]

Guides are right. Though to give specifics like that seems a bit odd. Be careful that it isn't something else impersonating him/her.

[pasc345]

Originally Posted by Shinsoo

Guides are right. Though to give specifics like that seems a bit odd. Be careful that it isn't something else impersonating him/her.

You mean like someone talking to me through channeling or telepathy?

[Miss Hepburn]

Originally Posted by Shinsoo

Guides are right. Though to give specifics like that seems a bit odd.
Be careful that it isn't something else impersonating him/her.

I know, right? Seems 'different'.

[WhiteWarrior]

Some other spirit trying to be helpful, maybe. Or it could be your guide. I dare say you will know if the information is right come christmas.

[Rah nam]

Originally Posted by pasc345

I heard the voice of my spiritual guide a few time ago telling me that I will see a certain person on Christmas time. It was very clear.. it almost felt like I was talking to another person.
I would like to know... is it for sure that what the guide said will happen... or can the guide be wrong sometimes? should I expect it?

Guides, your No 1, is not right nor wrong. He or she has a greater overview and with this might have a some accuracy in what most likely will occur.
Nothing is set in stone everything is in flux.
Having said this, I find it odd, a No 1 would give you strait out information.
As well, I don't know how this connection came about and what question from your side were asked.

[keokutah]

Originally Posted by Rah nam

Guides, your No 1, is not right nor wrong. He or she has a greater overview and with this might have a some accuracy in what most likely will occur.
Nothing is set in stone everything is in flux.
Having said this, I find it odd, a No 1 would give you strait out information.
As well, I don't know how this connection came about and what question from your side were asked.

Why is it odd that spirit guides and guides would give you straight out information? They can and will because they are guides, teachers, friends, etc, they can literally help you with anything and tell you anything, if only you are receptive, skilled and open enough to hear it. Just because you can't hear your guides teling you straight forward information, doesn't mean it doesn't happen for other people, all of our spirit guides and guides are different and can offer us different things.
I hear it all the time, spiritual people saying "my spirit guides are too vague, or they don't help me because they want me to figure it out for myself" but the truth is, you just aren't hearing them right. They don't talk in puzzles to get you to figure it out yourself, that's just what happens when you aren't hearing them clearly.

[Blue Tiger]

Originally Posted by keokutah

Why is it odd that spirit guides and guides would give you straight out information? They can and will because they are guides, teachers, friends, etc, they can literally help you with anything and tell you anything, if only you are receptive, skilled and open enough to hear it. Just because you can't hear your guides teling you straight forward information, doesn't mean it doesn't happen for other people, all of our spirit guides and guides are different and can offer us different things.
I hear it all the time, spiritual people saying "my spirit guides are too vague, or they don't help me because they want me to figure it out for myself" but the truth is, you just aren't hearing them right. They don't talk in puzzles to get you to figure it out yourself, that's just what happens when you aren't hearing them clearly.

Rather judgmental sounding, keokutah. But whatever. The guides I've encountered generally do not give clear answers; this I know from speaking to my own and those of others.

But if you find guides who will explain it all to you, keokutah, that's completely fine with me. I am not threatened by differing opinions, even when I feel they may be off the mark.

I am cautioning against assuming that every voice we "hear" is a guide. No more, and no less. If that somehow offends you, I am very sorry for you.

Make of that what you like, O.P.

[keokutah]

Originally Posted by Blue Tiger

Rather judgmental sounding, keokutah. But whatever. The guides I've encountered generally do not give clear answers; this I know from speaking to my own and those of others.

But if you find guides who will explain it all to you, keokutah, that's completely fine with me. I am not threatened by differing opinions, even when I feel they may be off the mark.

I am cautioning against assuming that every voice we "hear" is a guide. No more, and no less. If that somehow offends you, I am very sorry for you.

Make of that what you like, O.P.

If you don't get clear answers, then you need more practice because you aren't hearing them right, that is not their fault, you just need to strengthen your psy-abilities more. They do the best they can to relay you information but if you aren't able to recieve it and translate it properly it is going to come in unclear. That takes a lot of work to master.

And you seem pretty threatened even though you say you're not, that wasn't my intention. Just because other people have the same experience as you, doesn't mean I'm wrong either, they too are obviously not hearing their guides properly.
I've met tons of people who can, and I am also a person who can, I've been doing this for a long time.
People like to get egoful and blame their experiences on their guides, without taking into consideration that they simply made a mistake or there was a misunderstanding in the actual communication, and that happens a lot. There is no need to be so quick to blame it on your guides.

Can I ask what makes you think the voice was your guide?
Did hearing the voice feel wrong?

I look at my guide as separate to my spirit team, my guide I like to think of as guiding and prompting me, maybe putting a thought or two in my head but hearing my guides voice would be wrong.
My spirit team give me a sense of something, in that knowing way that they do but I don't want to hear voices as clear as if I'm talking to someone, that too would be wrong......for me anyhow.

As for a guide being wrong, I hope so! I want freewill