Just a personal opinion here, relating to me only.... telling people I consider myself "wise" seems a little arrogant. I don't feel in the slightest bit "wise".

I guess (once again, just my opinion) wise implies a comparison with someone else who isn't wise, and my path is not comparative to others. It's my path and I don't really connect it to anyone else.

Also, don't really go in for the "mystique" that some people want, so have no real desire to "leave them guessing".

I really am happy with the title Pagan. Not really sure why so many people have an issue with it.

Probably over analysing it and as I say, really is not meant as a judgement on anyone else.