So what you're saying is... it is impossible for anyone to enter the astral (like when they die) with any sort of negativity in their nature. As soon as someone dies or astral projects, they immediately become pure and just, and never again consider acting negatively in any way towards anyone. The astral is a paradisical heaven where everything is fluffy and warm.

That's astounding, because I've gone into the astral and intentionally/accidentally hurt people and caused pain. Wow, I guess I must be the first negative entity EVER, what are the odds

So yeah, your distinction between the physical and the astral does not work, unless you're saying people become pure angels as soon as they astral project/die. You're also saying that negativity can exist here but not there. Doesn't make sense.